So I am actually simultaneously working on a few companies. I started a blog on the process of starting a company at scrubadoo.com/blog and this is one of the posts from it. I thought it was very applicable for conrohl.com as well.
Before I get into this I realize that classifying anything into two groups is very difficult and there are always going to be those people that are both, none, or any combination of the two. That being said I have had the distinct opportunity to meet many people over the last few years with entrepreneurial aspirations and I have found that people usually fall into one of two categories; accidental idea people and entrepreneurs at heart.
An accidental idea person is someone who are happy doing whatever it is they are doing but while in their normal everyday routine they come up with an idea that turns them on to entrepreneurship. An entrepreneur at heart is someone who knows they want to do their own thing and while they may be in a normal job they are always looking for the right idea or opportunity to break out into the realm of self-employment. There are those lucky few that both want to be entrepreneurs and have a great idea at exactly the right time but I have found that those are the exceptions and not the rule. Neither road is easy and both groups have major mountains to climb.
I would say that the majority of entrepreneurs initially fall into the same category as me, an entrepreneur at heart (or at least most of the people I have run in my circles). I can't tell you the number of times I have had a conversation that basically goes like this: "I want to start my own company but I just don't have a good idea and I am just not an idea guy." In fact, these words have come out of my mouth on more than one occasion.
I now think about this statement and although there is definitely some validity to it, I mostly think it is b.s. There are a ton of ideas out there that you can be successful with, you don't need to come up with the next iPod. Look at conrohl.com or scrubadoo.com, in no way are we reinventing anything. We are taking in idea in a market we like that has a ton of players and we are going to try and do it better. There are thousands of good ideas out there you may need to network and talk to people that have them (find an accidental idea guy) but they are out there.
I think the biggest issue with this group is the risk. Entrepreneurship is difficult and stressful. Especially when you are comfortable or have other options on the table that you know would insure your continued stability. I have a theory that every one in this group needs a catalyst that makes them stop talking and actually take the leap (and very few people that talk actually do take the leap).
For me business school was my catalyst. I left a comfy job that I was succeeding in to go to business school. In my mind I justified the move as a catalyst to my entrepreneurial aspirations. I was afraid if I stayed at a cushy job I truly enjoyed with a company and people I still respect and invest in for too much longer I would never have the guts to go for it and start my own thing. So I left and went to school with the plan to start a company before I left. I had no ideas but I had the drive. Even while at school I felt the pressure of the money and stability of the more traditional job tracks. I interviewed with a ton of companies and was extremely close to accepting an offer from a consulting firm.
The point is, is that it is very difficult for entrepreneurs at heart to make that leap and take all the risks associated with it. The risks and stress certainly aren't for everyone and there is ABSOLUTELY nothing wrong with going the more traditional route. For my entire life I have believed I would run my own company and I know how difficult for me it was to take the leap. I am pretty sure my story is fairly common and to anyone with a similar conundrum I would say this: Understand the risks, cover your ass, but then just do it. You will never know unless you try and lets be honest you can probably always get a similar cushy job again but can you always sell scrubs to health-care professionals or open a quick service dumpling shop (another company I am working on).
For those accidental idea people I admittedly don't have as much advice or experience in this area but I think it comes down to many of the same things. You need to learn, or find people that know, how to turn your idea into a business. Just like my group you just need to give it a shot. Do it in an intelligent way that subjects you to a level of risk that you are comfortable with but do it.
I apologize for the long post but I really do want to encourage everyone to do it and give it a shot and "I don't have an idea" doesn't need to be something that holds you back, especially in an environment like a business school.
-Brett